Successful weed control in soybean combining herbicides and mechanical techniques

wide view of soybean seedlings growing between corn stalks on a farm

Soybean is a summer crop that is suited to mechanical weeding. The relatively low profitability of this crop means that alternative and more economical techniques need to be found.

The weeding strategy has to be effective during the first two months of growth. It is very important that certain species, such as nightshade (toxic), xanthium (stains soybean seeds), and datura (toxic and stains), are controlled for human consumption. As such, mechanical weeding can complement herbicide solutions for the most difficult weeds.

Problem weeds for soybean crop: 

  • Ragweed 
  • Thistle
  • Hedge bindweed
  • Wild buckwheat
  • Summer grasses (Panic grass, foxtail, crabgrass)

Weeds highly regulated for human consumption:

  • Jimson weeds
  • Nightshade
  • Xanthium

Agronomic context and challenges

Soybean offers valuable agronomic benefits thanks to its flexibility in crop rotations and its ability to fix atmospheric nitrogen, improving soil fertility for subsequent crops. Its planting window also aligns well with stale‑seedbed techniques, allowing multiple weed‑control operations before sowing. While soybean tolerates later planting dates, timing remains crucial to avoid water stress, especially for non‑irrigated fields, making careful management of seeding schedules an essential part of successful crop establishment.

Rotations

Soybean fits nicely between crops with different biological cycles. It just needs to be planted in plots with little risk of summer-crop weeds. Due to its very good capacity to fix atmospheric nitrogen in the soil, soybean returns a good share of its nutrients to the soil, which is great for the following crop. As such, it can be planted before a nitrogen-hungry crop to reduce input requirements.

Unlock success with crop rotations

Stale seeding, delayed seeding date

As with sunflower, the planting period for soybean is conducive to stale seeding, which should be carried out quite early, depending on the soil type.
Soybean is well adapted to a later seeding date, which means that one or more stale-seeding operations can be carried out beforehand. It should not be planted too late though, as it could suffer from a shortage of water. Non-irrigated soybean can be sown up to May 15th, whereas irrigated soybean can be sown as late as May 25th, no problem.

Comparing different weed-control strategies for soybean

Modality1️⃣Mecha TW2️⃣Mecha RH3️⃣Pre-emergence + HE post4️⃣Pre-emergence + HR post5️⃣Pre-emergence6️⃣Chemical ref
Pre-emergenceTine weederRotary hoePendimethalin 800 g/haPendimethalin 800 g/haPendimethalin 800 g/haPendimethalin 800 g/ha
Post-emergence from 1st leaf to 25 cm high1 to 2 tine weeder passes1 to 2 rotary hoe passes1 to 2 tine weeder passes1 to 2 rotary hoe passes-2x imazamox 25 g/ha (at 2-3 leaves then 10 days later)

Effectiveness of different cultivation methods on simple flora (annual mercury, black nightshade and white goosefoot):

 
 
 
1️⃣ 
2️⃣ 
3️⃣ 
4️⃣ 
5️⃣ 
6️⃣ 
 Satisfaction threshold

Source: Weed management in soybean crop, Terres Inovia, 2020

Economic assessment of the different methods
 Workforce €/ha
 Mecha tools costs €/ha
 Spraying costs €/ha
 Herbicide costs €/ha
 Costs in €/ha
 Working time min/ha
economic assessment of different methods of weeding strategies for soybean

Hoeing strengthens herbicide performance in fields with complex weed pressure

% Pendimethalin 920 g/ha / Imazamox 50 g/ha
% Pendimethalin 920 g/ha / Imazamox 50 g/ha + hoeing

2016 soybean trial (82)
Final efficacy (%) of the pre-emergence then post-emergence programme

Possible treatment periods depending on mechanical weeding tools

Crop stagePre-emergenceGerminatedStemSpread cotyledons1st unifoliate leaf1st trifoliate leafHeight 10 to 25 cmHeight 25 to 50 cmWeed stage
Rotary hoe🟢Pass possible
15 – 20 km/h
🟢Pass possible
15 – 20 km/h
⚠️Pass prohibited🟠With care
10  km/h
🟢Pass possible
10 – 15 km/h
🟢Pass possible
10 – 15 km/h
🟢Pass possible
10 – 15 km/h
⚠️Pass prohibitedWhite filament to 1st leaf
Tine weeder🟢Pass possible
8 – 10 km/h

Aggressiveness:
●●●
🟢Pass possible
8 – 10 km/h

Aggressiveness:
●●●
⚠️Pass prohibited🟠With care
2  km/h

Aggressiveness:
🟢Pass possible
3 km/h

Aggressiveness:
●●
Pass possible
4 – 5 km/h

Aggressiveness:
●●●
Pass possible
6 – 7 km/h

Aggressiveness:
●●●
⚠️Pass prohibitedWhite filament to 3–4 leaves
Row-crop cultivator⚠️Pass prohibited⚠️Pass prohibited⚠️Pass prohibited⚠️Pass prohibited🟠With care
3 km/h
with plant protectors.
🟢Pass possible
5 km/h
Depending on guidance equipment
🟢Pass possible
6 km/h
Depending on guidance equipment
🟢Pass possible
7 - 8 km/h
Depending on guidance equipment
3 leaves
and more

Weed-control programmes for soybean

ModalityPre-emergenceCotyledons1st unifoliate leaf3–4 true leaves4-5 leavesRow-crop cultivator pass limit
BBCH0-9101113-1414-1515+
Option 1 All chemical🟢💦  🟢💦  
Option 2 Mixed, with row-crop cultivator🟢💦  🟠💦  
  🟢⚙️ or ↘ 1 - 2 passes
🟢row-crop cultivator
1 - 2 passes
🟢row-crop cultivator
Option 3 Mixed, without hoeing   🟢💦  
🟠⚙️ or ↘ 🟢⚙️ or ↘   
Option 4 All mechanical🟠⚙️ or ↘ 1 - 2 passes
🟢⚙️ or ↘
1 - 2 passes
🟢⚙️ or ↘
1 - 2 passes
🟢row-crop cultivator
1 - 2 passes
🟢row-crop cultivator

🟠optional 🟢essential 💦chemical ⚙️rotary hoe or ↘ tine weeder

Purely chemical

In general, two applications are necessary to weed soybean, combining a pre-emergence root herbicide, and a second herbicide, post-emergence. Different solutions are possible, mainly imazamox-based for post-emergence. The product should be adapted to the weeds on the plot. 

Mixed strategy, with a row-crop cultivator

For soybean, a mixed weeding strategy is at least as effective as a purely chemical one. Combining a pre-emergence weed-control product with row-crop cultivation kills the new weed shoots (summer grasses, for instance). 

Mixed strategy, with a tine weeder

If it is not possible to use a row-crop cultivator, you can use a tine weeder or rotary hoe early in the cycle, to limit the growth of grasses like ryegrass, and then apply a chemical product later, post-emergence. 

Purely mechanical

Without herbicides, it is important to sow soybean in rows so that you can pass with a row-crop cultivator at the end of the cycle. Grasses can prove difficult to manage. It is necessary to weed with the row-crop cultivator regularly during crop growth.

Recommendations

Just like sunflower, there can be a lack of chemical solutions to destroy difficult dicots in soybean. In addition, certain toxic weeds are subject to very strict controls for human food outlets, so mixed weeding methods can be a good solution for this crop.

Sources:
Blind Cultivation for Early-Season Weed Control in Organic Grains, Fact sheet series 22-2, Ograin (University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2023
Désherbage mécanique du soja, Terres Inovia, 2019
Gestion des adventices en soja, Terres Inovia, 2020
Stratégies herbicides pour désherber le soja, Terres Inovia, 2025